Robot 6

Jen Van Meter responds to comments on that Power Girl/Cyclone scene

justnoLast week Esther Inglis-Arkell over at the 4thletter called out a scene in the recent JSA: 80 Page Giant comic where Cyclone and Power Girl have a discussion about the latter’s costume … or, more specifically, the great big hole right in the middle of it.

“Are you kidding me? I’m getting an ‘I choose my choice’ speech from a fictional character?” Inglis-Arkell wrote. “Feminist fans are getting a slap because they won’t accept one bullshit excuse after another for why male heroes are mostly fully-clothed and female heroes mostly walk around in their underwear?”

That original post sparked up quite the discussion around the ‘net, not only at the 4thletter, but also at The Beat, Jezebel, Comics Alliance and right here at Robot 6, among many others.

You’d think that sort of attention might send the story’s writer, Jen Van Meter, running for cover, but instead she shows up in the 4thletter comments section to explain her intent when writing the story.

“A friend forwarded me links to your post and to a couple other blogs that have picked up on your comments, and I feel compelled to reply because you’re right — I failed in what I was trying to accomplish with the ‘Spin Cycle’ story, or, at the very least, I failed you and many of your respondents,” Van Meter posted.

Inglis-Arkell pulled the comment out into its own post, which I encourage you to read … it isn’t often you get to see a writer offer insight into a story where they “misstepped,” as Van Meter notes.

News From Our Partners

Comments

8 Comments

The Ugly American

December 1, 2009 at 9:47 am

At this point, it’s logistics. The boob window affects aerodynamics, and ne’er has a writer addressed this. Unless her suit itself is Earth-2 Kryptonian in origin, and resistant to bloat-due-to-incoming air, I think I’d enjoy being the villain seeing Power Girl coming at him at high speed. Her costume should make her look like Bouncing Boy after every flight.

And don’t get me started about the “hide items in the bosom” concept; any item placed there would be shoved so far down after every flight, she’d need stirrups to extract them.

The Ugly American, it’s not about the boob window, it’s about the excuses surrounding it.

I love the artwork in JSA.

– Nick
from City of Kik
http://nickleshi.blogspot.com

The Ugly American

December 1, 2009 at 11:30 am

It’s all about the boob window.

The phrase “Boob Window” has just entered my personal lexicon. Thanks, gang.

The Ugly American

December 1, 2009 at 12:11 pm

Defined as the time during which you can boob.

Since Paul Levitz created the character, I’m curious what his original character description said or if he had any input on the costume and the reasoning behind the hole.

Everytime this is brought up, I die a little inside. Even after typing up my own feelings on the issue (screw the BS, its not a misstep, and the scene was a decent one Jen), I STILL feel my disdain for the internet grow just a bit.

Leave a Comment

 



Browse the Robot 6 Archives