Robot 6

The Fifth Color | A Widow’s worth

captainamerica-winter-soldier-15Captain America 2 posters, everybody!

Yep, this year’s Marvel kickoff film is Captain America: The Winter Soldier, due out April 4 (which is a little weird considering the studio historically releases its films the first week of May, giving Free Comic Book Day a boost), so we’re starting to get that media blitz a-rollin’ with teaser trailers, Super Bowl spots and the like. However, nothing will be seen as consistently or as widespread as the movie posters.

Keep in mind, posters are a little boring these days, especially for action films. There’s a certain color palette used, that gray-blue shine and airbrushed effect that has become shorthand for “cold and hard.” You know, like an action hero. But I digress. The movie posters released for Captain America: The Winter Soldier have the traditional “‘people walking at you from a horizon line,” two different profiles of Cap with headgear on or off, Nick Fury looking like Samuel L. Jackson looking mean and, the one a lot of people are talking about: Black Widow.

There’s just something about Natasha. Everyone has an opinion about Black Widow as a character, about Scarlett Johansson’s body shape and about what the retouching of photos does to our perception of beauty and realistic expectations of women. A single image has caused so much of a stir, I can only imagine what people will do when she actually shows up in the film. Because we can’t talk about Johansson’s performance and Natasha’s place in the storyline, let’s focus on the poster.

WARNING: No spoilers, but if you’re sensitive to body issues, I understand if you’d want to skip this one today. Everyone is beautiful, Photoshopped or not, voluptuous or rail thin! Now let’s go complain about a celebrity.

captainamerica-winter-soldier-07aRight off the bat, there’s that stupid blue overlay I hate in posters like these. Oh, everything’s all cool and blue and deadly or something. I don’t get it, I don’t like it, but we’re not here for the color tones. We’re here for Natasha, seen here with some pretty obvious Photoshopping. Honestly, most posters like this are Photoshopped to some degree, as when you blow up someone’s face to be plastered on a billboard or side of a bus, blemishes and imperfections are going be airbrushed out to make people look better. The Avengers movie poster was Photoshopped to a similar extent, but while that movie poster went out of its way to show of Johansson’s assets, shall we say, this poster is fairly straightforward. We’re also looking at her from a kind of funky angle, just a little bit downward so we see the underside of her chin. Her body language is big and open despite the Hellicarrier and fighter planes behind her, not exactly the most accurate depiction of a Russian super-spy assassin. It might not even be that accurate a depiction of the actress herself.

Should it be?  One Tumblr user noted that Black Widow’s pose was reminiscent of Botticelli, and now when I look at the poster, I sort of imagine The Birth of Venus, but with more aircraft and guns, and it makes me smile. Shouldn’t these posters look a little weird to get your attention and spark debate? Aren’t we talking about Captain America: The Winter Soldier right now?

At the same time, it’s a character poster, with no “backup” dancers to make sure we care that this is Cap’s movie. No twisting spine poses that overtly sexualize her position when juxtaposed with her co-stars. If anything, it proves she’s a major draw for the film, and considering how many of these Marvel Cinematic Universe movies she’s been in compared to the rest, she could probably get her own movie down the line. Another Tumblr user, fuckyeahblackwidow, put it extremely well when she said she didn’t think there was enough Photoshopping.

from fuckyeahblackwidow.tumblr.com

All in all, it seems like a lot of noise about a static image that isn’t immediately offensive. Was she Photoshopped to look thinner or better-looking? Most likely. Will this reflect on Black Widow’s role in the film? Not int he slightest, unless there’s a scene that involves walking openly along the Hellicarrier while jets fly by. Images aside, what does she actually do?

blackwidow_gunsBlack Widow carries a gun. Two guns, in fact, and I was rather surprised I wasn’t as upset by this as several well-respected friends and colleagues of mine were. I do understand their position the more we talked about it: The gun isn’t the most heroic of weapons, and seems shortsighted in the wake of real-life gun-related tragedies that kids are seeing superheroes wield them. It also takes a little something away from the fantastic-ness of the Avengers world; a god of thunder, a living legend, a monster and a woman with a pistol. I mean, it puts her one ahead of poor Hawkeye, but I understand the disconnect. These movies, despite being PG-13 for the most part, are aimed at kids and when the heroes use lethal force it sends the wrong message.

But on the other hand, does Natasha really execute anyone openly in the films? She’s an assassin and talks openly about the “red in her ledger’, things she’s done in her past that she’s not proud of and is openly working to make amends for. She’s trying to be a better person and will use everything at her disposal to do what’s right, including the skills that got her in the red to begin with. It’s actually pretty cool to see someone who is a mere mortal in a leather jumpsuit stand tall next to Thor and Captain America and be considered their equal. She is part of that awesome Marvel element of humanity woven into their story themes, that everyone can make a difference regardless of superpowers. Or of how wrong they were in the past.

Black Widow is awesome; she’s had a dynamic MCU showing and has a surprisingly deep background for a supporting character. She’s incredibly versatile, standing side by side with gods and legends as well as working behind the scene in black-ops fashion. Let’s face facts: Natasha is completely ready for her own film; spy movies are popular, Johansson is a fine actress and has done good work as Black Widow, and it would be neat to see yet another style of film come out of Marvel Studios. Also, how much would people flip out if Black Widow had a movie before Wonder Woman? Am I right?

This movie poster doesn’t break the Black Widow or send out any new messages about her strength or her character. I, for one, can’t wait to see what she’ll do in Captain America: The Winter Soldier! So maybe it’s content and actions we should be judging rather than appearances and marketing. Then again, Quicksilver’s costume for X-Men: Days of Future Past is atrocious …

News From Our Partners

Comments

5 Comments

While they HAVE liquified her, the white highlights along characters body’s always tend to slim them down more. And this has always been a lighting technique that photographers used before photoshop to slim and chisel people’s features. Even liquifying was a dark room method before photoshop existed since I think the 60′s at least?

Captain America is ALSO liquified to have a an iconic slim V shape silhouette. And he’s liquified frame by frame in the first movie as well. Some people inside the industry also claim that both him and Hemsworth also had prosthetics added to their bodies for their shirtless moments on top of the fact that they had to work out hard and gain a lot of muscle mass for the role.

The thing is, Fury and Captain America in those posters look determined, bent on action and powerful. Black Widow’s guns are lowered and seem loosely gripped. Her hair is flowing in the wind and the type of pace she seems to keep(it is a still picture, but you can infer it from the posture and such) is more at home on the catwalk that in the field. We’ll see whether or not she’ll kick ass in the movie, but there is a completely different message you get from the posters for The Winter Soldier.

I’m a huge Captain America fan but I won’t be hanging that one on the wall. It looks atrocious. The colour scheme, the silly walking poses that don’t seem to match up with other characters. Bleh. And Widow looks like she’s starring ina Michael Bay film, or Motley Crue video.
These characters have appeared in hundreds of comic covers in classic, and character defining poses. Cap holding his shield on high, Widow crouched and deadly evoking the name of her character for chrissakes! I know they don’t invest much money in posters these days but this is pathetic.

I like how Fury is looking at the back of Cap’s head like someone’s buzzed the word, “asshole” there! That bastard Winter Soldier up to his old shenanigans!
Cap looks like someone scratched his Al Jolson records, and Widow looks so bored that she’s about to do the hippy-hippy shake. “Don’t need nothing, but a good timee…” she sings to herself thinking back to her days as a Poison groupie and back up dancer. “Sleeping with Brett Michaels… so much red in my ledger, how will I ever make up for that?”
Winter Soldier has that expression on his face thinking, “What the f#ck man! They walked right past me! Who the f#ck do they think blew up the Hellicarrier! Hang on… is that the word asshole on the back of Cap’s head!
And Robert Redford, his character once again taking inappropriate power walks during a crisis! In front of an explosion no less. Sylvester Stallone is wiping away a tear somewhere.
And last, but not least, the Falcon… the Falcon… hello… anyone?.. anyone?

Sorry, that’s not Captain America. I have fifty years worth of comics to prove it.

Leave a Comment

 



Browse the Robot 6 Archives